USSRs Recognition of Azad Hind Govt

iVarta.com

	Classifieds, Jobs, Yellow Pages, Real Estate, Property, Blogs, Ticketing, Forums
	Business, Social and Community Networking
	Worldwide Website Open Directory Listing

Forum Home

Latest Discussions

Sitemap

India News Discussion Forum, Comprehensive Collection Information Resource Library. Articles, Columns, Analysis Research Papers. Facts about India, Yoga Meditation Ayurveda Indian History, Culture, Religion, Politics, Business, Terrorism. Mystery Diversity Rich information resource, global Indian community Asia. Guide New Headlines Views, Discussions, Comments Archive Library. Indus Valley Culture. Religious Indians, History Invasion, Hindu, Hinduism, Christianity, Islam. Jammu and Kashmir, international relations USA, Russia, UK, Pakistan, China and more

USSRs Recognition of Azad Hind Govt
India Forum: Comments, Opinion - Information Resource

News Summary: For the people brainwashed by false propaganda, it is difficult to recognize the truth. That is particularly true about the Indian population fed with gigantic propaganda unleashed by the Government of India and the historians attached to the government since 1947 against the memory of both Subhas Chandra Bose and his Free India Government in exile. Although it is a fact that along with Germany, Italy, Japan, the Soviet Union also has recognized the Free India Government established in 1943 in S.....read more in: USSRs Recognition of Azad Hind Govt

Add your comments here

Name

Comments that include profanity or personal attacks or other inappropriate comments or material not following our Guidelines - Report Abuse) will be removed from the site.

Use proper/valid names: NO url, NO Email id. Comments with names like "ABCD", ".." are deleted.
Spammers: Don’t waste your time here. Comments copntaining Commercial/SPAM/Ad words are not listed.
Comments containing Website URL will be listed ONLY after review by our Editors (it may take few hours for the review)

Comments
Total 41 Comments

These comments are about: USSRs Recognition of Azad Hind Govt

Srno	Comment on Current Thread
43	S.Ghosh on Nov-10 : Samirbaran Das: You said, "JAPAN WILL AGREE TO KILL NETAJI WITH A PURPOSE TO BUY SOME FASCILITY FROM BRITISH" Britain was in no position to dictate terms to the U.S, who has provided money and food to Britain to survive. Britain was a bankrupt nation in 1945-46, admitted by Stafford Crips, the Foreign Secretary of Britain in 1947 to justify the indepedence of India by saying Britain was powerless to hold the Indian Empire. General MacArthur, the Supreme Commander of the Allied army in the Pacific, declared clearly that "only USA would invade Japan, noone else, British and Australian could come later just to mop up"; in these exact words. As an Irishman( originally ) he used to hate the British.He had never allowed Britain to have any access to Japan or Korea. Britain had nothing to say about the Japan"s Empire and the ruling class. USA had decided to allow the Emperor and some of the ruling class of Japan to take over the country after the American occupation. In the same way NAZIS who had surrendered to the Americans were not killed, but allowed to emigrate to South America and some of the leading Nazis were even allowed to take over Germany after 1948. There was no deal between Japan and Britain, but there were a number of deals between Japan and USA and Japan and USSR( who was happy just to take over half of Shakhalin island but could occupy practically the whole of Japan, if it wanted to, but did not). I suggest you to read the books by Purabi Roy; there you can see letters written by Netaji to Molotov and Jacob Malik in 1945, before he went to USSR. There are documentary evidence from the NKVD-KGB files, given by Purabi Roy in her books that Stalin, Molotov, and Mikoyan were discussing what to do with Netaji in 1946.
42	Mohan on Nov-10 : S. Ghosh, Thank you. This is exactly what happened. Regarding your #4 Dr S.Radhakrishnan was "shown" Netaji from a distance during the former"s visit to u.s.s.r. We have ditched India"s greatest son, Prince among Patriots, in 20th century. >>1) There was no plane crash in Taiwan on those days, one month before and after 18 August 1945. 2) There are documentary evidence that Netaji entered into USSR, even the British secret service knew that and reported it to Nehru. 3) There are documentary evidence that Netaji was alive in the USSR in 1946. 4) A number of people have seen Netaji in 1946 in USSR, that may include in 1948 Sarvapalli Radhakrisnan
41	Mohan on Nov-10 : Hello SAMIRBARAN DAS, your views on Netaji and Azad Hind Fauz show that you are a Cong stooge. Atleast you should study about Netaji and the various commissions properly before coming to half-baked conclusions. S. Ghosh has the views right. Justice Mukherjee commission emphatically concludes that Netaji did not perish in the Taiwan flight despite various "authentic sounding proofs and testimonies" - Nehru knew this and exploited this by feeding to the same lies by his liar commission. The tradition followed through all the rest of the PMs, save Lal Bahadur Shastri who smelled a rat in the theory but could not do much as he was finished. The cong had mortal fear of Netaji as he was the most deserving and popular leader who towered over everyone else. Netaji was not done in by Germany-Japan. 7 Countries including Japan recognized him as Head of Indian nation and treated him so. The years of 1944-1948 were so complex that Netaji ended up aligned against the eventually victorious powers in the WW-II, and in all probability became a Prisoner of War jailed in the U.S.S.R. Congress party is refusing to divulge the secret papers and details under the RTO act saying it will create fissures ( read fissures in Cong bottoms, to start with ).
40	SAMIRBARAN DAS on Nov-09 : "US plan to save the king was not known to british ?"- "No, British were not at all consulted by the American regarding the invasion of Japan, Korea, Manchuria, Formosa, Guam, The Phillipnes. These were pure American affairs". - BRITISH AND AMERICANS WERE IN SAME SIDE. THEY MAY PALY MANY POLITICS. BUT ULTIMATLY THRY PLAYED SAME GAME. THEY AGREED TO GET NETAJI KILLED BY JAPAN AND ACCORIDINGLY FUTURE US-UK-JAPAN AXIS WILL START. NETAJI MURDER WAS THE FIRST GAME OF THIS AXIX. "Japan spread the story of an aircrash( which never took place) to save the life of Netaji from the British agents, who wanted to kill Netaji on the spot, as demanded by both Lord Mountbatten ( great friend of Gandhi-Nehru-Patel) and General Wavel." - NO! NO! NO! NEVER JAPAN ADMITTED THAT THEY HAVE FABRICATED A FALSE AIR CRUSH STORY TO SAVE NETAJI"S LIFE. JAPAN IS THE FABRICATOR OF THAT STORY. SO THEY TO BE SUSPECTED. WHY WHY WHY YOU WANT TO BE DEFENDER OF JAPAN WHO ARE ALREADY SPEAKING LIES. " Japan was in position in 1945 to do anything. It was totally defeated, all its cities were in ruins, people were starving to death." - SO IT IS POSSIBLE THAT JAPAN WILL AGREE TO KILL NETAJI WITH A PURPOSE TO BUY SOME FASCILITY FROM BRITISH. THEY PURCHASED THEIR KING"S LIFE. EMERGENCE OF JAPAN AS AN ALLY OF AZAD HIND IS SORT OF PRINTING MISTAKE OF HISTORY. JAPAN WAS NOT SYMPATHETIC TO INDIAN FREEDOM.
39	S.Ghosh on Oct-14 : Samirbaran Das: "US plan to save the king was not known to british ?" No, British were not at all consulted by the American regarding the invasion of Japan, Korea, Manchuria, Formosa, Guam, The Phillipnes. These were pure American affairs. Japan spread the story of an aircrash( which never took place) to save the life of Netaji from the British agents, who wanted to kill Netaji on the spot, as demanded by both Lord Mountbatten ( great friend of Gandhi-Nehru-Patel) and General Wavel. Japan was in position in 1945 to do anything. It was totally defeated, all its cities were in ruins, people were starving to death.
38	SAMIRBARAN DAS on Oct-13 : if japan is not the killer of netaji , why they spread the lie regarding his death. the liar is to be suspected. who spread the false story of taihoku air crash ? the japan only. US plan to save the king was not known to british ? the british - US played the game to befool their new enemy ; the freedom-loving indians. both british and US wanted that if india gets freedom, it should be within the range of their politics. netaji"s plan was to free india outside the range of british politics. because of US-british politics, india attained freedom within british-americal political framework. netaji murder was their first act; of-course , japan helpd them. so japan killed netaji and joined US-British political framework.
37	S.Ghosh on Oct-10 : There are documentary evidence discovered by Prof.Purabi Roy in her books, published by the Asiatic Society, that Netaji had reached USSR and lived at least until 1946. According to Satyanaraan Sinha, former Ambassdor of India to USSR, Netaji was in USSR. He was never killed by Japan. There was no plane accident, as revealed by the Taiwan Government, BBC and at last by the Mukherjee Commission. British were ignored totally on the affairs of Japan by General MacArthur, who made the decision to keep alive the Emperor and his family, and most of the politicians and officers of the Japanese government. It was not just Netaji, but Sukarno, Aung Sang, political leaders from Malay, Vietnam, Thailand, China, Mongolia, were good friends of Tojo, the war time Prime Minister of Japan, who helped them all in their independence movement.
36	SAMIRBARAN DAS on Sep-03 : SINCE JAPAN HAS CIRCULATED THE LIE ABOUT NETAJI"S DEATH, SO JAPAN IS TO BE SUSPECTED FOR THE WRONGDOING. JAPAN WAS NOT MUCH FRIENDLY TO INDIAN INDEPENDENCE. IT WAS A CHANCE OF HISTORY THAT THEY ACCEPTED AZAD HIND FAUZ AS THEIR ALLY. JAPAN WAS HAVING THEIR OWN IMPERIALIST AGENDA. MR DEBNATH DAS , ONE CLOSE FRIEND OF NETAJI SUSPECTED JAPAN"S ROLE LONG AGO. THE ATTITUDE OF BRITISH TOWARDS JAPAN"S ROYAL FAMILY SPEAKS THE MYSTERY. BRITISH AND JAPAN RESTORED THEIR PRE-WAR ALLIANCE AND JOINTLY CONDUCTED NETAJI"S MURDER. SO NETAJI NEVER REACHED USSR. HIS PROGRAMME TO START SECOND FREEDOM STRUGLE WITH THE HELP OF RUSSIA FAILED.
35	SAMIRBARAN DAS on Sep-03 : SINCE JAPAN HAS CIRCULATED THE LIE ABOUT NETAJI"S DEATH, SO JAPAN IS TO BE SUSPECTED FOR THE WRONGDOING. JAPAN WAS NOT MUCH FRIENDLY TO INDIAN INDEPENDENCE. IT WAS A CHANCE OF HISTORY THAT THEY ACCEPTED AZAD HIND FAUZ AS THEIR ALLY. JAPAN WAS HAVING THEIR OWN IMPERIALIST AGENDA. MR DEBNATH DAS , ONE CLOSE FRIEND OF NETAJI SUSPECTED JAPAN"S ROLE LONG AGO. THE ATTITUDE OF BRITISH TOWARDS JAPAN"S ROYAL FAMILY SPEAKS THE MYSTERY. BRITISH AND JAPAN RESTORED THEIR PRE-WAR ALLIANCE AND JOINTLY CONDUCTED NETAJI"S MURDER. SO NETAJI NEVER REACHED USSR. HIS PROGRAMME TO START SECOND FREEDOM STRUGLE WITH THE HELP OF RUSSIA FAILED.
34	SAMIRBARAN DAS on Sep-03 : SINCE JAPAN HAS CIRCULATED THE LIE ABOUT NETAJI"S DEATH, SO JAPAN IS TO BE SUSPECTED FOR THE WRONGDOING. JAPAN WAS NOT MUCH FRIENDLY TO INDIAN INDEPENDENCE. IT WAS A CHANCE OF HISTORY THAT THEY ACCEPTED AZAD HIND FAUZ AS THEIR ALLY. JAPAN WAS HAVING THEIR OWN IMPERIALIST AGENDA. MR DEBNATH DAS , ONE CLOSE FRIEND OF NETAJI SUSPECTED JAPAN"S ROLE LONG AGO. THE ATTITUDE OF BRITISH TOWARDS JAPAN"S ROYAL FAMILY SPEAKS THE MYSTERY. BRITISH AND JAPAN RESTORED THEIR PRE-WAR ALLIANCE AND JOINTLY CONDUCTED NETAJI"S MURDER. SO NETAJI NEVER REACHED USSR. HIS PROGRAMME TO START SECOND FREEDOM STRUGLE WITH THE HELP OF RUSSIA FAILED.
33	S.Ghosh on Sep-01 : If the Japanese had killed Netaji, then who was in the USSR alive, at least until 1948. You are on drugs. Are you suggesting Japanese agents( when Japan was under the US occupation until 1952) went inside USSR and killed Netaji??
32	SAMIRBARAN DAS on Sep-01 : The story of taihoku plane crash is Japan"s fabrication. Since they have spreaded this lie , so they are to be suspected as probable murderer. The motive behind the murder is also clear. Japan killed netaji with a purpose to conduct appeasement of british and purchase safety & security for their royal family. Japan was a British ally in first world war and they restored their ealier links after defeat in Second world war.
31	S.Ghosh on Aug-29 : Lot of water have passed through the bridges since the Fraud Khosla Commission. Now read the Mukherjee Commission Report. It categorically said, there was no plane accident and Netaji never died in any plane accident in Taiwan.
30	SAMIRBARAN DAS on Aug-29 : Witness says Japanese killed Netaji (October 21, 1970) Netaji"s close associate Mr Deb Nath Dass, deposing before the Khosla commission said that "in 1954 he came to the conclusion that if Netaji had died it was not in the same plane and that the Japanese had played some foul game with them"
29	S.Ghosh on Aug-28 : Samirbaran Das: By repeating the same Ruibbish again and again many times you cannot prove your point. 1) There was no plane crash in Taiwan on those days, one month before and after 18 August 1945. 2) There are documentary evidence that Netaji entered into USSR, even the British secret service knew that and reported it to Nehru. 3) There are documentary evidence that Netaji was alive in the USSR in 1946. 4) A number of people have seen Netaji in 1946 in USSR, that may include in 1948 Sarvapalli Radhakrisnan. British had nothing to do with Japan, because General MacArthur, a very anti-British, did not allow any British to go there except for "moping up" in his own words. General MacArthur kept alive not only the Royal family but almost all members of the Tojo, except those who were directly responsible for the War. Several such cabinet members of Tojo later became PM of Japan later: Kishi, Tanaka. At that time Britain became a dependent country on USA, which kept it alive by giving money.
26	SAMIRBARAN DAS on Aug-27 : Japanese agents killed netaji in the fabricated air accident of taihoku. The air accident was planned by Netaji with a purpose to by-pass surender to british. However Japan used the same fabricated accident for different purpose, the purpose of bying security for their royal family. so they killed netaji by the same fabricated accident; appeased british and surved their purpose. The british forgiven japan king and not tried him as a war criminal.
25	S.Ghosh on Aug-25 : Samirbaran Das: There is a big hole in your story. There are documentary evidence from the Soviet Archive, that Netaji was alive in the USSR at least until 1946 or even further. A lot of people gave evidence that they have seen him in the USSR. Are you suggesting Japanese agents went inside USSr to kill Netaji?
24	SAMIRBARAN DAS on Aug-25 : THE TAIHOKU AIR CRASH WAS A FABRICATED PLANNED INCIDENT, PLANNED BY JAPAN SPIES AND NETAJI BOTH. NETAJI PLANNED TO DISAPPEAR FROM JAPAN SIDE AND RE-APPEAR AGAIN AS AN ALLY OF CHINA OR RUSSIA TO START ANOTHER ANTI-BRITISH WAR. THUS HE PLANNED TO AVOID SURRENDER TO BRITISH. THE SAME FABRICATED INCIDENT JAP SPIES USED FOR A DIFFERENT PURPOSE. ALTHOUGH THEY AGREED AT FIRST BUT LETTER ON PLANNED DIFFERENTLY. THEY SAVED THEIR ROYAL FAMILY AT THE COST OF ELIMINATION OF NETAJI. THIS EXPLAINS HOW HIROHITO AVOIDED TRIAL AS A WAR-CRIMINAL. BRITISH SPIES CO-OPERATED WITH JAPAN SPIES IN THIS REGARD.
23	S.Ghosh on Aug-19 : Samirbaran Das: It is better if you stop writing rubbish. You wrote, "The Taihoku air crash occured under Japanese control only". There was no air-crash at all at that time and the dates, so said the Government of Taiwan. Thus, the story of air-crash was invented. So, you have find out another rubbish to justify your rubbish.
22	SAMIRBARAN DAS on Aug-19 : Netaji Subhash chandra basu was killed by Japanese spies. Before second world war, British spies and Japanese spies were enough linked. Japan and British made many open agreement before second world war. Spies of both side played a key role in making these agreements. After the defeat of Japan, the Japanese spies restored their secret ( nearly open ) link with British, agreed to eliminate one British enemy ( Subhash) and purchase safety & security for their own royal family. Many Americans were interested to try Hirohito for war crime. But Churchil prevented. Why ? The Taihoku air crash occured under Japanese control only. They caused it along with Netaji. Netaji planned to disppaear from Japan side and reappear as an ally of china or russia to start another anti-british war. Why japanese will allow this ? is it not better to serve their own royal family than indian"s freedom strugle ? So ulitimaly netaji was killed by Japan to conduct appeasement of British.
21	SAMIRBARAN DAS on Jul-31 : NETAJI WAS KILLED BY JAPANESE SPIES. BEFORE SECOND WORLD WAR, BRITISH SPIES AND JAPANESE SPIES WERE ENOUGH LINKED. THERE WAS JAPAN - BRITISH OPEN AGREEMENT ALSO, WHERE BOTH SIDE SPIES PLAYED A ROLE. AT THE END OF THE WAR, JAP SPIES RESTORED THEIR LINK WITH BRITISH; AGREED TO ELIMINATE ONE BRITISH ENEMY ( SUBHASH) ; AND THUS PUCHASE SAFTY , SECURITY FOR THIER OWN ROYAL FAMILY. US WAS INTERESETED TO TRY JAPAN KING FOR WAR CRIME, BUT CHURCHIL SAVED HIM. WHY ? HERE LIES THE MISSING LINK. THE SO CALLED AIR CRASH WAS CAUSED UNDER JAPANESE ONLY. THERE WERE HOLDING THE KEY. WHY THEY WILL ALOW SUBHASH TO DISAPPEAR FROM THIER SIDE AND RE-APPEAR AS AN ALLY OF CHINA OR RUSSIA TO START ANOTHER ANTI-BRITISH WAR ? IS IT BETTER TO SERVE JAPANESE INTEREST THAN INDIAN INTEREST?
20	S.Ghosh on May-11 : The Statesman has published some of ots very old pages from 1920s recently so show that Gandhi had several meetings with Teggart, the notorious police-commissioner of Calcutta during 1920s. Teggart has personally killed a number of revolutionaries ( Kanailal, Jatin Sarkar) or tortured them to death to death before hanging them ( Surya Sen).
19	Mohan on May-09 : That was excellent Ghosh. Ironically, in spite of heap of machinisations/insults by Congress top brass, Netaji won presidency of the party twice, and also named his INA units after Gandhi, Nehru etc, and called Gandhi as Father of the Nation etc. The top crooks in the party did not realize that Netaji was honest, thorough patriot and above their petty machinisations and manipulations. Dear S. Ghosh / other Netaji fans, There is a yahoo group dedicated for Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose. Consider posting in the group, netajisubhash@yahoogroups.com Best wishes.
18	S.Ghosh on May-06 : Gokhle was awarded Knightwood for his service to the British Raj by undermining the Swadesi movement. He was the staunch enemy of the Swadesi movement. Then he went to London to have a discussion with William Gladstone, the British PM at that time. After that a decision was made by them to import Gandhi from South Africa, Gokhle went to South Africa to bring Gandhi to London where Gandhi was trainned by the British for about 6 months, before he went to India and with the help of the British media and pro-Brotish Marwari business community Birla and Bajaj in particular Gandhi was promoted without any election as the Dictator of The Congress. The first thing Gandhi did was to sabotage the Freedom Movement and start Khilafat Movement to reinstall the Sultan of Turkey. Then with the help of the British he has either expelled the geneuine freedom fighters from the Congress( Anne Besant, Chittaranjan Das, Bipin Pal, Srinivas Iyenger) or the freedom fighters were killed by the British police ( Lala Lajpat Rai) or died in mysterious circumstances( Tilak, Chittanranjan Das). Motilal Nehru was purchased by Birla, and Gandhi had determined that his son Jawaharlal would be the heir to him to promote the British Raj. That was the reason Gandhi had expelled Netaji Subhas from the Congress, along with 200 others, insulted the revolutionaries, was refused to recognize the revolt of the Indian Navy in 1946. It is unfortunate that the Indians even today do not know the truth.
17	S.Ghosh on Apr-30 : Common Sense: Govertment in exile is indeed priceless but not worthless. The French Government in Exile with its president De Gaulle recognized by all Allied powers made France a member of the UN Security Council The US Government in Exile with its head of the state General Washington was recognized by France and it became the legitimate government defeating the British. Azad Hind Government made the Independence of India possible. When the British had started the prosecution of the captured soldiers of the Azad Hind Fauz, there were revolt in the Indian Navy and Air=Force, because of it within a few days Clement Attlee declared in the British Parliament that Britain has no such army to keep the Indian empire and it must give it up. Zimbabwe got its independence nearly 40 years after India after fighting a very long war against the British. That could have happened to India without Azad Hind Fauz. It is well known, that, Gokhale, Gandhi, Nehru were British agents.
16	Mohan on Apr-30 : >>Governments-in-exile are priceless; even dirt commands a few rupees a bushel! And how dare you use the word "dirt" on a man who sacrificed everything he had to free India from clutches of Brits, taking highest possible risks. Okay, better than being back-stabbing slaves serving British Empire. If you Knew even a fraction about Netaji you"d have slapped yourself before you abused him. No wonder, we got what we deseved, not bravery but cowardice; not Princes among Patriots but Thugs and Losers. Jai Hind.
15	Dipak on Apr-29 : Anybody interested to know more about Netaji should look fo Anuj Dhar on the google.
14	common sense on Apr-29 : Governments-in-exile are priceless; even dirt commands a few rupees a bushel!
13	S.Ghosh on Apr-28 : Khosla was a classmate of Subhas Bose in Cambridge, could not pass the ICS ( just like Nehru)but Subhas Bose did , so became a Barrister with a grudge against Subhas Bose. That was the reason he was selected for the Second Investigation Commission and rejected every evidences but accepted only those approved by the Gandhi-Nehru family. Mukherjee Commission received only hostility, but no support from the India government, who refused to open the files already in the hands of the Government.
12	Dipak on Apr-27 : Anuj Dhar used to work for Hindusthan Times. He is no longer there. What happened? Interested reader may look at www.missionnetaji.org.
11	Dipak on Apr-27 : Shah Nawaz was a spy supplying information to his brother who was working for the British.
10	S.Ghosh on Apr-27 : I read in the Hindustimes Probe organized by Anuj Dhar that the typist of Nehru gave evidence to the Khosla Commission that Nehru has sent a telegram to Clement Attlee the then PM of Britain informing him that Netaji went to the USSR in August 1945 but then organized the ShahNawaz Commission to prove that Netaji died in Taiwan in 1945.
9	Mohan on Apr-22 : British slave Nehru was a heartless crook. He instituted fake commissions and declared Netaji dead even though he knew and involved govts around the world knew that Netaji was alive. Nehru cospired to keep Netaji captive and out of public eye. Entire history of India as taught in schools has blood in its hands. India"s most well-known Freedom Fighter and Prince among Patriots and First Prime Minister does not have a respectful account in the history.
8	A.Moron on Apr-21 : Nehru has supressed all credits due to Azad Hind Government and the role played by the revolt of the Indian Navy in 1946 in response to the British trial of the Azad Hind Fauz members. That revolt has forced the hands of the British to give up their colony in India. Otherwise Indian people would have to fight for another 20 years or more as the African or Indonesians did. We take for granted that British were very kind, they just listened to RamDhun of Gandhi and went away. That is not real history but a manufactured history by the Gandhi-Nehru family.
7	A.Moron on Apr-21 : Nehru has syprred all credits due to Azad Hind Government and the role played by the revolt of the Indian Navy in 1946 in response to the British trial of the Azad Hind Fauz members. That revolt has forced the hands of the British to give up their colony in India. Otherwise Indian people would have to fight for another 20 years or more as the African did.
6	S.Ghosh on Apr-20 : I have read in Anuj Dhar"s book "Back From the Dead" that Radhakrishnan has seen Netaji in a prison in USSR from a distance. In order to keep his mouth shut Nehru offered him Vice-Presidentship and later Presidentship.
5	Truth Speaks on Apr-19 : Very analytical article. Must read for every iVarta reader.
4	Dipak on Apr-19 : Feedback sent to author. Most of the files dealing with Netaji disappeared from Indian govt. office for some unknown reason. India got its independence not through non-violence movement of Gandhi,who criticised violent movement against British Raj. In fact, there was mutual love between Gandhi and the British.INA was very popular with Indian army.Indian army and Navy was in revolt moodas INA soldiers went on trial. British realised, they can"t rule India without the support of the Indian military,so they wisely decided to leave India. Mr. Clement Attlee , ex-prime minister of UK, while on a visit to Kolkata, was asked about Gandhi"s role in independence of India,he smiled and told Gandhi had little role to play in the independence of India. Mr. M. O. Mathai wrote,"Bose"s understanding of international affairs remained astonishingly poor or perhaps he did not want to understand anything which was not in linewith his pre-conceived notions. ....Bose was a complicated person, a born fighter and a born loser." He also wrote, " Subhash chandra Bose was free from communalism and obscurarantism. He was a truly liberated person who possessed many of the quality needed in a great leader of a vast country with its infinite variety, religious and linguistic." ( My days with Nehru- M.O. Mathai. ) Is it true that NCERT book in India describe him as a "fascist"? I request all visitors to Kolkata to visit Netaji Bhavan.
3	Dr. Dipak Chakrabart on Apr-19 : Feedback sent to Author: Soviet-Unions-Recognition-of-the-Azad-Hind-Government Dipak Babu, Nice to read your account in Netaji, one of my two heroes, other being Swami vivekananda. It"s time you write a book on Netaji. Have you read BACK FROM DEAD by Anuj Dhar, describing Netaji"s post-war life. Warm wishes. Dipak (retired physician. Wales, UK and Madeira.)
2	Dr.Shriharsha Sharma on Apr-18 : Feedback sent to Author: Soviet-Unions-Recognition-of-the-Azad-Hind-Government It is clear to me now why the communists are anti India and anti Hindu but pro Muslims and pro Pakistan. I read in internet pages on DR.S.RADHAKRISHNAN that when he was ambassador to ussr then a member of politburo took him to a prison where he saw Netajee Subhaschandra Bose to see him from distance but not allowed to talk to him.He wrote a letter to J.L.Nehru did not take any action. Would you kindly throw some light on this. Netajee"s bith place is in ryins a shame on all of us mainly Congress. sharma
1	Mohan on Apr-17 : Great to note the correspondence between India"s First Prime Minister Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose and the U.S.S.R.
1

USSRs Recognition of Azad Hind Govt - Thread over

Current Threads

Jai at 22:55 Today : India can win Nobel for filth: Jairam Ramesh [1 comments]

Very well said,Mr Rmamesh like your party has created filth in the politics,so do common folks do for environments.

Jai at 21:47 Today : Pragmatic: Ms. Roy would approve [1 comments]

Please refrain from giving importance to the bird brained moth by comparing her with Army Chief.

g kapuria at 20:16 Today : Fundamentalist Muslim is the biggest threat to Ind.. [4 comments]

PH..I am with you. The fault is with the BJP. I cannot understand why they go with the Shiv Sena and MNS goondas.

	Other comments on this post
	Proud Hindu at 18:28 Today : We all must strongly denounce and condemn the violence and the gundagiri of the Shiv Sena and the MNS. Throw these bums out. They don"t represent me, a proud Hindu, in the least.

g kapuria at 15:31 Today : I strongly disagree. Secularists are the biggest threat to India. They shelter the fundamentalist muslims and christians. Secularist newsmedia do not report their misdeeds, which gives goondas like Bal and Raj Thackeray a platform.

Proud Hindu at 18:32 Today : WSJ: Grow Up, Indian Youngistan! [1 comments]

I prefer the catch phrases Younglandia, Youngpradesh, Youngstanam over "Youngistan."

g kapuria at 16:17 Today : SRPF jawans removed from Gateway of India, g... [2 comments]

CS.. you mean locals from across our western border, right?

	Other comments on this post
	common sense at 10:29 Today : Why not have 3 shifts of locals be the guards!

g kapuria at 16:14 Today : India at a "loss" over growing Sino-US ties: Chine.. [1 comments]

The chinese have bought this so-called Sino-US tie. Nothing to be at a loss about. US always sided with Pakistan, now they have new ties with China. Should we be concerned? It seems not, given the silence of the Congress govt.

Comments (till the day of this story)

g kapuria on Nov-09 : Assault on Azmi, suspension of MNS MLAs trigger pr.. [1 comments]

You needed a Muslim to deal with the Raj Thackeray and his crooks.

Mohan on Nov-08 : Yeddyurappa breaks down [1 comments]

Yeddi abhi drama band kar.
Move on and do something substantial.

S.Ghosh on Nov-07 : Left parties saved India! Rahul Bajaj [1 comments]

Correct Mr.Bajaj.
However,even the left parties could not save the public properties, Gold, diamond, coal, copper, oil, zink, and other mines. These are all taken over by great evils like Anil Agarwal, Ambani Brothers, De Bears, Laxmi Mittal etc etc, who are buying palaces in London by selling these public properties.

common sense on Nov-07 : Why should Modi apologise, asks Mohan Bhagwat [2 comments]

He should be tried for letting 200+ Hindus killed in guj; foret how many muslims were killed. These hindus definitely did not ask to be killed.

common sense on Nov-07 : "Supportive" Independents gain most in new H... [1 comments]

There is never a free lunch!

common sense on Nov-07 : CSIR asks sacked Indian American scientist t... [1 comments]

Out of job, out of palace. Indian born American should know the american way!

S.Ghosh on Nov-07 : Avoid Vande Mataram in Ramdev"s yoga camp: D... [1 comments]

Avoid India. The heritage of India is Hindu-Buddhists-Jain, all alien to the Muslims. thus, Muslis should all go to Saudi Arabia.

common sense on Nov-08 : "Advani to quit after new BJP president takes over.. [1 comments]

Advani"s next four months or more invisible leadership won"t make much difference in the fortunes of the party!

common sense on Nov-07 : What India needs: 500 new cities! [1 comments]

India needs population control more than anything else. It is easy to define what India needs, 500 new cities, or 5000. Need resources!

common sense on Nov-05 : No end to BJP"s troubles [1 comments]

Out with the middlemen - the central leadership. Take the head count and let the majority man rule!

USSRs Recognition of Azad Hind Govt

India Forum: Comments, Opinion, - Information Resource

Copyright and Disclaimer:
The views expressed in this forum are of the People/Visitors/Authors who post them and not of this website. The author is solely responsible for the contents of the Posts/Views/Opinions on this Discussion Board, Forums. This website does not represent or endorse the accuracy, completeness or reliability of any opinion, statement, appeal, advice or any other information in the Forum Posts. Our readers are free to forward this forum page URL to anyone. This forum posts may NOT be transmitted or distributed by others in any manner whatsoever (other than forwarding or web listing page URL) without the prior permission from this website.